Excel User Group
Microsoft Excel blogs, forums, files. Read, ask questions, provide answers.

Excel replacing comma with I in formulas

Latest post Fri, Apr 30 2010 2:06 AM by Nick Hodge. 3 replies.
  • Wed, Apr 28 2010 4:25 PM

    Excel replacing comma with I in formulas

    Hello,

    I'm having a very confusing issue with Excel. Anytime I try to enter a formula that needs a comma to seperate cells (like product or vlookup), the comma is replaced with an I (the letter). As a result I get the error message "the formula you typed contains an error". This happens when I manually enter the formula or when I use the formula wizard. To make is even more odd, the formula will work if I put a $ in front of the cell name. Here is an example of what I am talking about...

    =product(A2, B2) - this is what the formula should be, but this does not work

    =product(A2I B2) - this is what Excel does when I use the formula wizard, still gives me an error

    =product($A2I B2) - this ends up working and multiplying the two cells.

    I am using Excel 2007. It is driving me nuts. Any thoughts...?

     

    Thank you.

    • Post Points: 21
  • Wed, Apr 28 2010 5:54 PM In reply to

    • Nick Hodge
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on Sun, Dec 23 2007
    • Southampton
    • Posts 543
    • Points 9,287
    • MVP

    Re: Excel replacing comma with I in formulas

    I would take a look in your autocorrect list and see if it has a comma to replace with the letter. You could test this as the autocorrect is shared between office applications. e.g it should do it in word too

     

    Let us know if this doesn't work and we will investigate more

    Regards
    Nick Hodge
    Microsoft MVP, Excel
    Southampton, UK

    • Post Points: 21
  • Thu, Apr 29 2010 12:07 PM In reply to

    Re: Excel replacing comma with I in formulas

    I tried the autocorrect as well, it makes the change in Word, but in Excel it does not make the change. Formula's will not work with the comma. It seems to only work with an I or : as a seperator and with a $ in front of the first cell name. This is with any formula (sum, product, vlookup, etc.). Very odd...

    • Post Points: 21
  • Fri, Apr 30 2010 2:06 AM In reply to

    • Nick Hodge
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on Sun, Dec 23 2007
    • Southampton
    • Posts 543
    • Points 9,287
    • MVP

    Re: Excel replacing comma with I in formulas

    Albert

    Very strange. If there was an entry in Word and you deleted it then it should apply to all Office applications. Did you re-start Excel after?

    If that didn't work I would look at your regional settings (In windows control panel)

    Next, I would say to take a look at whether you have any strange add-ins at work or maybe a virus? Certainly never heard of it before.

    Is it this way on all workbooks, even a new one?

    Regards
    Nick Hodge
    Microsoft MVP, Excel
    Southampton, UK

    • Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 1 (4 items) | RSS
Copyright Excel User Group and the relevant contributors, 2010. All Trade Marks acknowledged. This site is a peer-to-peer site and NOT affiliated in any way to Microsoft Corp. All rights reserved.